I know Brian goes after the "Y", so when I saw his second guess had the last letter correct, I moved "dumpy" to my second guess
Nice piece of detective work there!
And of course, I'm flattered that I encouraged you to take a dump earlier than planned…
Unlike the rest of you targeting 4 vowels and 6 consonants in the first 2 lines, I now go for the 6 vowels—incl Y—and 4 consonants. So my first 2 words are…
AROSE
UNITY
…which also include the 4 most common consonants. Third word is decided based on the intel from the first 2 lines. Today was my first use of these new words, and it got me my first 3-line solve, so it'll be interesting to see if a larger sample size shows it's better.
you shouldn't look at my chart before playing the puzzle each day
Agreed. I play the puzzle, then come here.
Possible inaccuracy in Most Common Letters
I'm not set on my word choices yet, because the Most Common Letters list is based on all words found in a major dictionary. This may not be the same as the most common in 5-letter words.
I expect especially E, but also S, D, I and G are inflated in the general list due to all the words with ED and ES, plurals, and ING. Possibly L and Y are also inflated due to common LY ending. No doubt there are more such combos which also may feature less in 5-letter words.