What games in your wishlist have the worst reviews, and why did you wishlist it?

[neogunhero]

I totally missed @Zed Clampet 's thread last year on cleaning out your wishlist. I have 1041 games in my Steam wishlist and thought it would be fun to sort it by review score then go to the very bottom to see what games are reviewed the worst. It also got me thinking about what I saw in these games that intrigued me enough to add them.

What games in your Steam wishlist have the worst reviews, and what made you add them?

Starting with a well-known flop:

The Day Before on Steam

The Day Before offers players a uniquely reimagined journey into post-apocalyptic open-world MMO survival set in the present day on the US East Coast following a deadly pandemic.

store.steampowered.com

I like open world zombie survival games, and the trailers and screenshots were promising. Then came all the controversy around it, I'm glad I didn't spend any money on it. Luckily you can't buy it anymore.

However, this next game you can still buy:

Site Error

store.steampowered.com

Identity was poised to be the "Sims killer" before we had a mini wave of Sims-like games in the past year or so. The Kickstarter and trailer videos were all very promising. The main idea was to be a life sim MMO, where you lived in a city with other people and could completely decorate your apartment. This game went under my radar for the past few years, and it seems to be all but completely abandoned. The subreddit is pretty chaotic with people making tasteless insults towards the devs for scamming them out of money.

This next one is a bit of a surprise to me:

Kerbal Space Program 2 on Steam

Kerbal Space Program 2 is the sequel to the acclaimed space-flight simulation game Kerbal Space Program. Enter the next generation of space adventure with exciting new parts, stunning visuals, fully revamped UI and Map View, and rich new environments to explore.

store.steampowered.com

I was never huge into the original KSP, but I know it had a very dedicated following. I was excited for the new one and wanted to check out what was hopefully going to be a better version of the first game, but obviously that is not how it turned out. I'm not sure what happened here, why it isn't getting updated, and why they haven't been able to turn around the reception yet. Then again, it's only two years old, so hopefully there is a chance it will redeem itself.

Last game:

Test Drive Unlimited Solar Crown on Steam

TDUSC is a lifestyle and social experience that redefines what an open-world racing game can be. Explore a fully recreated Hong Kong Island. Take to the road behind the wheel of exceptional cars and live the ultimate life of luxury.

store.steampowered.com

This game had a lot of potential to replaced The Crew 2 after their servers shut down. Open world MMO racing game is the only kind of racing games I like, so this one had me excited. It came and went without me knowing, just to find out it's negatively reviewed for feeling unloved and soulless and being riddled with bugs. The trailers and screenshots would have you thinking otherwise.

 

[Pifanjr]

This next one is a bit of a surprise to me:

Kerbal Space Program 2 on Steam

Kerbal Space Program 2 is the sequel to the acclaimed space-flight simulation game Kerbal Space Program. Enter the next generation of space adventure with exciting new parts, stunning visuals, fully revamped UI and Map View, and rich new environments to explore.

store.steampowered.com

I was never huge into the original KSP, but I know it had a very dedicated following. I was excited for the new one and wanted to check out what was hopefully going to be a better version of the first game, but obviously that is not how it turned out. I'm not sure what happened here, why it isn't getting updated, and why they haven't been able to turn around the reception yet. Then again, it's only two years old, so hopefully there is a chance it will redeem itself.

I wouldn't hold your breath on the game redeeming itself:

Kerbal Space Program developers confirm layoffs are coming at the end of June

The number of layoffs is not yet confirmed, but it sounds like the entire team is being let go.

www.pcgamer.com

 

[Johnway]

The worst score for a game probably falls into the "mixed" category, besides games i absolutely want, the games on my Wishlist are more on my to watch list. Stuff i saw that looked interesting or played fine but not essential in my collection. So i add them in for later review. turns out some of those games aren't all that hot.

 

[Pifanjr]

As for my wishlist, out of the 26 entries (of which 7 unreleased), the worst reviewed one is the The Hunter & The Beast DLC for Total War: Warhammer II at 61%. One of the legendary lords is apparently almost unplayable and the other one has a disappointing campaign, so the only reason to buy it is to get a couple extra units.

The worst reviewed full game is SFD : Rogue TRPG at 86%, so I guess I have impeccable taste (and also clean up my wishlist every so often).

 

[Frindis]

I got one overwhelmingly negative reviewed game and it is the same as the one you have @neogunhero called The Day Before. I believe I wishlisted it because it showed some promise, but we all know how that turned out...

Cities: Skylines II on Steam

Raise a city from the ground up and transform it into a thriving metropolis with the most realistic city builder ever. Push your creativity and problem-solving to build on a scale you've never experienced. With deep simulation and a living economy, this is world-building without limits.

store.steampowered.com

On my wishlist because I liked the first one. It got mixed reviews because of bugs, crashes and the like. Might take it for a spin in a couple years.

Delta Force on Steam

Delta Force is back! The iconic series returns as the definitive free-to-play modern team-based tactical shooter and featuring three distinct gameplay modes: large-scale PvP warfare, intense extraction shooter action, and a remake of the legendary Black Hawk Down campaign.

store.steampowered.com

Wishlisted because I played the beta and found it to be decent enough. Not played it since, mixed reviews because of cheaters, crashes, queue times, loot balancing. Hopefully they manage to iron out the worst of it.

Silverfall on Steam

Silverfall, a once glorious city, lies in the fantastical Kingdom of Nelwë, where the forces of Technology and Nature are strongly opposed. Symptoms of this terrible conflict have begun to manifest physically as melded cyberbiologic organics and living steam-driven automatons.

store.steampowered.com

Old RPG game that caught my interest. Mixed reviews because it's old and janky, but I can live with that.

 

[DXCHASE]

I thin my list regularly so most of my wishlist games are not out yet. Lowest score on mine currently goes to: Terminal Velocity and im not really sure why i still have it wishlisted tbh.

But, i was also looked into Identity. I saw your post and then read the post underneath. I wonder how many people were actually working on it? Been in EA for over 6 years and steam warns theres been no update since before then. But it seems someone close was responding in the post below yours.

 

[Zed Clampet]

I've got 707 games wishlisted. I don't have anything below "mixed" because I recently got rid of them.

This was a bizarre game that I wishlisted in 2015. It was only $5 and I always said I was going to buy it, but this was before I lost my mind and bought everything. So a few weeks ago, I suddenly remembered this and discovered it's been removed from sale. Probably stopped working and the solo developer didn't feel it was worth his time to update it.

Site Error

store.steampowered.com

This is a CRPG that I looked forward to for a very long time and anxiously awaited reviews for only to see it completely tank. The developers were in trouble because their publisher closed down, and they had to release it before it was done. They have been religiously updating it for over a year now, but no one is buying it and the reviews aren't getting better for some reason. In fact the 4 most recent reviews are all negative, which makes me kind of sad. I'm going to keep watching it, though.

Save 50% on Broken Roads on Steam

Broken Roads is a story-rich, party-based RPG set in a decaying, post-apocalyptic version of the vast Australian Outback, featuring a genre-redefining morality system. Survive, form bonds, and make tough choices that will shape your dangerous yet mesmerizing 25+ hour journey across the wilds.

store.steampowered.com

@neogunhero Dean Hall is making a spiritual successor to Kerbal since Kerbal 2 got shut down.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9a5OnL8NwoE&ab_channel=ShadowZone

 

[Pifanjr]

This is a CRPG that I looked forward to for a very long time and anxiously awaited reviews for only to see it completely tank. The developers were in trouble because their publisher closed down, and they had to release it before it was done. They have been religiously updating it for over a year now, but no one is buying it and the reviews aren't getting better for some reason. In fact the 4 most recent reviews are all negative, which makes me kind of sad. I'm going to keep watching it, though.

Save 50% on Broken Roads on Steam

Broken Roads is a story-rich, party-based RPG set in a decaying, post-apocalyptic version of the vast Australian Outback, featuring a genre-redefining morality system. Survive, form bonds, and make tough choices that will shape your dangerous yet mesmerizing 25+ hour journey across the wilds.

store.steampowered.com

I recognise that name. It was once a very promising new game, it's unfortunate it didn't work out:

CRPG renaissance on hold as one of our most anticipated games gets a last-minute delay to next year

I'm expecting a name change to Fixed Roads.

www.pcgamer.com

 

[Zed Clampet]

I recognise that name. It was once a very promising new game, it's unfortunate it didn't work out:

CRPG renaissance on hold as one of our most anticipated games gets a last-minute delay to next year

I'm expecting a name change to Fixed Roads.

www.pcgamer.com

It also got hit by a group of people angry that the game took some sort of grant and included indigenous people in the game. It was something like that, anyway. I really didn't try to understand it. Also, there was a very long thread on the forums about all the starting characters being angry women.

There was a lot of nonsense as people passed the time between missed launch dates. Outrage spread like kudzu.

 

[Zloth]

Sid Meier's Civilization VII on Steam

The award-winning strategy game franchise returns with a revolutionary new chapter. Sid Meier's Civilization® VII empowers you to build the greatest empire the world has ever known!

store.steampowered.com

On my list because it's CIV! I didn't like 6 very much, though, and reviews for this one are under 50% positive. I was thinking 'wait for two expansions' but, looking at the store page, they've already got quite a bit of DLC. This ain't looking good, and Firaxis needs a win badly.

 

[Colif]

site error seems to be a popular game on this list

I only have one game on my wishlist, having bought the other one this month... might play it one day.

Civ 6 changed game too much, hence reason I didn't even think to buy it.

 

[Smellincoffee]

I don't have a huge wishlist (12 titles, some of which are DLC), but the two lowest are:

Nebuchadnezzer. Added because I liked the Impressions city builders when I was younger, and this is inspired by them. However, I've never bought it because I know full well that I will play it a few times and then forget about.

Police Simulator: Patrol Officers. I like simulators and this one seemed interesting.

Both are ranked "Mostly Positive".


Just for fun,, I looked at the other categories. I have two OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVEs (Schedule 1, Wylde Flowers) and the rest are VERY POSITIVE.

 

[Zed Clampet]

I don't have a huge wishlist (12 titles, some of which are DLC), but the two lowest are:

Nebuchadnezzer
Police Simulator: Patrol Officers.

Both are ranked "Mostly Positive".


Just for fun,, I looked at the other categories. I have two OVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVEs (Schedule 1, Wylde Flowers) and the rest are VERY POSITIVE.

This game is a lot less "cozy" but is a very good police game:

The Precinct on Steam

Averno City, 1983. Gangs rule the streets and your father lies restless in his grave. Clean up the city, uncover the truth, and embark on thrilling vehicle chases through destructible environments in this neon-noir action sandbox police game.

store.steampowered.com

 

[Smellincoffee]

This game is a lot less "cozy" but is a very good police game:

The Precinct on Steam

Averno City, 1983. Gangs rule the streets and your father lies restless in his grave. Clean up the city, uncover the truth, and embark on thrilling vehicle chases through destructible environments in this neon-noir action sandbox police game.

store.steampowered.com

Ohhhh, I like the looks of this. Thanks!

 

[BeardyHat]

Looks like the lowest on my list is Expeditions

Expeditions: A MudRunner Game on Steam

Embark on scientific expeditions with this new off-road adventure game. Lead research missions as you drive a variety of all-terrain vehicles, using high-tech tools and managing your camp and crew to ensure your success in the wild.

store.steampowered.com

Sitting at Mixed. I have it on there because I really love Snowrunner and after trying the demo, I think Expeditions is totally my jam as well. It's mixed reviews are unfair, in my opinion.