My girl's been going hard on Phasmophobia with a couple of our friends, but I think any horror game that you play together is inherently less scary. While you are communicating you're focused on each other rather than the game, making the impact of both the visuals and the sound design less pronounced. It just detracts from the experience a bit, no matter how cool the idea behind the game is.
My favourite way to play horror games will always be by myself in a dimly lit room. I have fond memories of playing System Shock 2 and hearing the voice of SHODAN talk to me as if the sound was coming from inside my own cybernetic mind. It creeped me the hell out. Or what about the creepy gorefest that is Resident Evil 7? I think that game nails the eerie atmosphere. You never feel quite at ease. Maybe right after a boss fight or a chase, but it doesn't last. Alien: Isolation comes to mind as well, for the same reasons.
I don't get 3rd person horror games, now that I think about it. If you're playing a character it's hard to get as invested and you won't be scared half as much as a result. If it's me doing the walking and interacting, then it can be extremely effective. I know a lot of people swear by games like Silent Hill, but I don't know, that just doesn't do it for me. If you're going with 3rd person horror, make it campy and a bit more action-y like Resident Evil 2 Remake.
You know what else is a horror game? Escape From Tarkov. It's not meant to be one, but holy **** is it ever.
My favourite way to play horror games will always be by myself in a dimly lit room. I have fond memories of playing System Shock 2 and hearing the voice of SHODAN talk to me as if the sound was coming from inside my own cybernetic mind. It creeped me the hell out. Or what about the creepy gorefest that is Resident Evil 7? I think that game nails the eerie atmosphere. You never feel quite at ease. Maybe right after a boss fight or a chase, but it doesn't last. Alien: Isolation comes to mind as well, for the same reasons.
I don't get 3rd person horror games, now that I think about it. If you're playing a character it's hard to get as invested and you won't be scared half as much as a result. If it's me doing the walking and interacting, then it can be extremely effective. I know a lot of people swear by games like Silent Hill, but I don't know, that just doesn't do it for me. If you're going with 3rd person horror, make it campy and a bit more action-y like Resident Evil 2 Remake.
You know what else is a horror game? Escape From Tarkov. It's not meant to be one, but holy **** is it ever.