I replay more games each year than new games, or games from my bloated backlog. There are also games that are "remastered " like
Diablo 2 Resurrected, or games that have "enhanced editions" like
Baldur's Gate 1 & 2. I've played all three of those this year and they could arguably be called replaying, as the stories and mechanics are basically the same as the originals from years ago.
There are some games that I mod, like
Skyrim (surprise!),
Fallout 4 & Fallout New Vegas. The mod variety is just so vast, that every replay is a bit different, sometimes dramatically so. I replay those games roughly every 12-18 months or so for a few hundred hours. I don't always finish them, but with those games, it's not so much the main story that drives the game (or me), it's just that open world exploration the story that you can create for yourself that keeps pulling me back.
Story-based RPGs like the
Mass Effect games (even
Andromeda) and the
Dragon Age games I replay frequently. I know the stories and the characters, but all of those games just has a certain "feel" to the entire experience that I'm always drawn back to them. I find it hard to actually define that quality, but I haven't experienced it in any of the newer games I've played. I had hopes for
Outer Worlds, and while it was a decent game, it just fell short in so many aspects.
Plenty of games are made to repeat.
Exactly this. I think most of us here have games that draw us back into certain game worlds, and while players criteria may differ, that lure to go back to certain games is always there.
Witcher 3, for example, is easily my favorite RPG but I only played through it once. If I went through again right now, I'm sure I would find some new twists on the minor stories, but most of it would be a repeat
Witcher 3 is high on my current replay list. I've been holding out because CD Projekt Red is supposedly working on a remastered version. I had hoped that it would be released this year, but I know now from a recent PCG article, that it's been bumped into 2022, so I'll probably hold out until that releases.
I replay games all the time—if you were to ask me what I'm playing at some particular time, there's a good chance it's a replay, but only from a fairly narrow selection of games I really like.
It's mostly an all or nothing thing—if I really like a game it goes on the replay roster, otherwise it's a once and forget.
Yes and Yes. Some games I play once, and even if I enjoyed them, I really have no desire to go back to them. Other games, some of which I've listed above, I'll always go back to at some point.