, I was 51 the year it released and played it. Fear did give me a few jump scares, and it definitely had moments that had a very creepy/eerie atmosphere at certain points. I think by that point in my life that my senses were somewhat dulled to horror games/videos/books. I'm so old, I can remember watching the original Friday the 13th movie when it released in theaters. As @ZedClampet
said, I think it depends on the individual and the different (and amount of ) horror medium you've been exposed to. There are still things that can weird me out, like spiders. I have severe Arachnophobia.