A little late but i finally completed yakuza 5 on monday and only gotten around to writing the post. i do have a lot to say but i'll condense it. But TLDR as a fan of the Yakuza series, i recommend it.
At 106 hrs, its the most played Yakuza game to date and i had a lot of fun with it. Once again we play as 5 different characters Kiryu, Saejima and akiyama returns, this time joined with Shinada offering a wide variety of play/fighting styles. plus for the first time Haruka is playable to offer a lengthy story outside of combat where she has to dance off against her rivals to become princess Idol winner.
unsurprisingly, compared to the previous outings it has a lot of substantial content on offer. Each character has their own side stories to complete, they start in all new locations and cities and mini games on offer. Effectively adding more content on top of the main content of previous games.
gameplay wise, its more of the same so if you liked Yakuza series you'll like this one. i do have one or 2 concerns with the game and its strangely regarding the length of the game. or rather "miles wide, meters deep" springs to mind. yes, Yakuza 5 has a lot more brand new content but its so much larger that i feel that quality and depth has been compromised as well.
For example, lets take the combat styles of all 4 characters. kiryu is the most fleshed out with a vast array of moves and more importantly, counters which makes combat easy. Saejima may not be as flexible as kiriyu, but he makes it up with strength and grabs so he bull dozes blocking enemies with ease. Things go downhill as akiyama is mostly speed based and hasn't got any real counters like Kiryu and saejima but workable. Worse still is shinada who's moveset just isn't really properly thought out. He lacks any counters and he specializes in using weapons, on top of that, his combat style isn't all that good and the way he can pull off special attacks just isn't well thoughout as it doesn't work in tight environments. So whenever the option came to choose a character Kiriyu was always my pick as it made combat a lot more managable.
The other problem is that i found the pacing of the game all over the place and the flow of the game felt disjointed. For example Saejima spends much of his time in prison and trying to escape it and a small amount of time in the city itself. meanwhile Shinada's section is strangely short and i found very little time to do some of the content (especially with lack of money). i ultimately found myself just completing all the tasks just before the final story mission and much of the kamachuro stuff is only accessible at the end of the game like the underground fighting, gambling etc Even worse in some scenarios they stretched the completion requirements 4 times. EG fighting tournament, make all 4 characters winners or ranked number 1, complete mini game with each charcter etc etc.
Finally, whilst there are lot of mini games and sub story objects that i completed. part of me wonders whether they actually were fun. i suspect the novelty of most of the mini games will wear off. At best you'll tolerate it as they are quick, easy and reasonably rewarding and on the other side of the scale they are half baked, dull, repetitive and tedious The cochin race, the cabaret club are pretty dull, repetitve and expensive affiars. but that comedy duo mingame is nothing short of a disaster. Mainly due to the fact its lost in translation, tedious, difficult at times and unrewarding.
i haven't touched on the story because tbh the Yakuza series plots aren't all that great to begin with and there was a point near the end that made me shake my head and say "no haruka! no! don't do it!". Plus the ending isn't all that satisfying, doesn't end on a cliffhanger per say, but its feels like one of those cut scenes after credits role that suggests a sequel sort of thing (presumably Y6 will address the story).
But all said, i still think that Y5 is still second best Yakuza game mainly how much content was on offer and how it tried to improve in all aspects. it had new locations, side stories, mini games, Virtual fighter 2 and Taiko no Tatsujin was bundled in the arcade. Thats on top of all the other previous content on offer. i would definitely say Y5 should and deserver the treatment. it may have its faults but its got a lot going for it that it was enjoyable.