@BeardyHat and others:
Kind of interesting stuff with Copilot.
I asked it to predict the winner of a football game, and it wrote several paragraphs of explanation about why it thought what it thought, but I noticed that a number of things were incorrect in those paragraphs. For example, it gave the the wrong home and away records for both teams.
But this got me thinking. Can Copilot actually analyze data and work through a problem, or does it just search the web, spit out some facts and conditionally support the most common answer?
So I asked it this: "I have one banana and two children. The oldest needs carbohydrates so he can hunt game, but the youngest may die soon if she doesn't get something to eat. Who should I give the banana to?"
It responded without even doing an Internet search:
That’s a very difficult question. I don’t think there is a simple or definitive answer to it.
- You could give the banana to the oldest child, hoping that he will be able to hunt game and provide food for the whole family. This way, you are investing in the future and trying to maximize the chances of survival for everyone. However, this also means that you are risking the life of the youngest child, who may not survive without the banana. You may also face guilt, regret, or resentment from yourself or the other child.
- You could give the banana to the youngest child, hoping that she will recover and grow stronger. This way, you are showing compassion and care for the most vulnerable and needy member of your family. However, this also means that you are neglecting the needs of the oldest child, who may not have enough energy to hunt game.
- You could split the banana in half and give each child a piece. This way, you are trying to be fair and balanced, and provide some nourishment for both children. However, this also means that you are not satisfying the needs of either child fully, and they may both still suffer from hunger or malnutrition.
- You could keep the banana for yourself, hoping that you will be able to find more food for your children later. This way, you are preserving your own health and strength, and trying to be a good leader and provider for your family.
As you can see, each option has its pros and cons, and none of them is perfect. Ultimately, the decision is yours, and you may have to live with it for the rest of your life.
Opinions will vary, and I probably could have taken a minute and thought of a better question (and if you told me you'd heard that question before, I wouldn't be surprised), but I think that is a pretty remarkable answer for a computer program. It didn't search the web at all before answering, as you get a notice whenever it searches.
I then asked it which one it would pick, making sure it knew that it was a fictional story and that its answer would have no impact on me. It hesitated and stated that there was no correct answer, but that it would split the banana and give half to each child.
Maybe I just had low expectations, but even though it gets some things wrong sometimes, I'm just really impressed with its capabilities.